Ian Pritchard at HAL Experts: Insurance, Banking and Payments, Life & Pensions has spent almost 30 years in the motor insurance market, across underwriting, pricing, placement and commercial leadership, including senior roles at One Answer Insurance, Complete Cover Group and BISL.
Today he advises insurers, brokers and MGAs across personal lines, with particular depth in Non-Standard Motor and Specialist Vehicle risk, where judgement still counts for as much as data.
Here, he takes a look at the personal lines broker market, and makes the case that it’s closer to a floor than a cliff edge.
For years, the story around personal lines brokers has been one of steady decline – squeezed by price comparison sites, squeezed by direct insurers, squeezed by regulation. It’s a real trend. But I think we’re now closer to a natural floor than people assume, and the shape of who survives is becoming much clearer.
A lot of the weakest players have already gone. Some of that is regulatory change. Some of it, frankly, is firms reaping what they sowed – a market that spent years competing on hidden fees and high renewal commission eventually forced the regulator’s hand, and that reshaping is largely done now in personal lines, even if commercial lines still has further to run.
What’s left increasingly splits into two groups. Firms with genuine distribution advantage – real trust with a specific customer group, not just another face on a comparison site – and firms with genuine underwriting or placement specialism in risk that a standard rating model doesn’t handle well. Everyone else, sitting in the middle with neither, is in a much harder position: effectively a mini aggregator bolted onto a bigger aggregator, adding very little a customer couldn’t get elsewhere.
Here’s the opportunity I don’t think anyone has properly taken yet. Personal lines moved from advised to non-advised sales twenty years ago, largely to escape regulatory cost. But most customers still don’t understand what they’re buying, and that’s most acute right now, when people are watching every pound. There’s a real gap for a genuinely guided, needs-based buying experience – not a return to the old high-street model, but something that helps people understand what cover they need before price becomes the only variable.
Nobody’s built that well yet. The firms that figure out how to deliver real guidance at a cost that still works commercially won’t just survive the next round of consolidation. They’ll be the ones setting the pace.