HAL Expert
The Ogden discount rate, used to calculate lump-sum payments in personal injury claims, significantly impacts motor insurance pricing. When adjusted downward, as it was in 2017 from 2.5% to -0.75%, it increases the size of the lump sums insurers must pay out, spiking claims costs. Conversely, an upward revision (now expected) reduces those lump sum values paid to claimants.
The 2017 cut sent shockwaves through the industry, with leaders losing sleep over how to adjust pricing to account for potentially hundreds of millions of pounds in higher claims costs. After each insurer made their individual adjustments, the industry as a whole raised premiums significantly across most motor insurance products, with higher premium young drivers the most affected.
Now, as the rate nears review again and interest rate changes could produce a more favourable adjustment, the question arises:
Will insurers be equally swift in passing the benefits back to customers through lower pricing?
Will Insurers Share the Windfall?
The past few years have been turbulent for UK motor insurers, with few, if any, able to achieve an underwriting profit. Reserves have been depleted to support financial results. If the revised Ogden rate provides a potential windfall of tens or hundreds of millions, insurers face a choice: use it to rebalance their books or drive growth by maintaining or lowering premiums.
With the insurance cycle trending upwards but consumer finances constrained, sharing any Ogden windfall through lower pricing could prove a calculated strategy for insurers seeking market advantage. However, sceptics question if the historically volatile cycle and an uncertain regulatory outlook permit such foresight.
The looming Ogden review promises high stakes for insurers and an early opportunity for the Labour Government to set out its stall.