Insurance Crystal Ball 2025

Insurance Crystal Ball 2025: HAL Experts Make Their Predictions

Picture of HAL Experts
HAL Experts

We gathered our HAL Experts team for some crystal ball gazing into 2025. Here’s what they’re betting on. We’ll return in late 2025 to see who is Mystic Meg and who is Michael Fish:

Ian Exworth: PCW Power Plays

“Don’t expect UK price comparison to sit still; the leading players (who now pretty much own general motor insurance distribution) are likely to face significant regulatory and market pressures of their own, with focal points maybe including customer journeys, value products, cross sell, data & AI and commission disclosure.

“Motor saturation means we can probably expect a renewed push by the PCWs into other markets like Pet or SME, whilst PCW ownership and changing motivations may also see the competitive intensity increase between the PCWs once again in 2025.”

 

Darren Mccauley: Market Consolidation & Margin Pressures

“2025 will be defined by significant consolidation in the personal lines market, with major acquisitions creating both disruption and opportunities for others to gain market share. Meanwhile, deteriorating combined ratios, Judicial Guidelines changes, and sustained claims inflation will push technical margins into concerning territory.

“The accelerating transition to electric vehicles will compound these pressures, with constrained repair networks and substantially higher premiums testing both insurers’ capabilities and customer tolerance. Expect heightened regulatory scrutiny around APRs and Consumer Duty implementation to add further complexity to an already challenging market.”

 

Colin Robertson: The Great Insurance Divide

“As the smokescreen of rate increases clears and CORs start to head in the wrong direction, the comparative deficiencies and advantages in core operating models will become more obvious and the divide between the winners and the losers will continue to grow. An opportunity for some. More consolidation may be on the horizon for others.”

 

Dan Freedman: Cars chaos, and Robot Drivers

“In the ongoing ZEV Mandate tussle, UK Government and legacy OEMs will agree that the problem is consumer demand. The insurance industry may be asked to put our hands on the scales in some way…

“And just when we’re dealing with that drama…Get ready for the robot uprising! Our industry will realise in 2025 that Tesla has cracked full self-drive. Sci-fi will become sci-fact and those questions about who and what we insure in 2030 and beyond will re-emerge with a vengeance.”

 

Stuart Forrester: Weather and Customer Frustrations Both Heating Up!

“ Despite average temperatures on the rise will we see some extremes in 2025- cold snap early in the year and flooding?  watch out for event frequency. Customer frustrations likely to boil over in respect of claims. Which insurers will be called to account?”

 

Andrew Goldby: Regulatory Robustness and Tech Troubles

“Expect the FCA to change its stance to be more robust with the industry in 2025.

“The technology provider landscape is also likely to see some consolidation, with market pressures potentially leading to a reduction in the number of viable competitors.”

 

Paul Upton: Property Problems and DA Drama

“The whispers about UK property prices may be about to turn into shouts. The market’s been tiptoeing downwards, but 2025 is when we may see a real tumble.

“Meanwhile in the Delegated Authority space – some big-name capacity providers may take their chips off the table. I don;’t expect the DA landscape to look the same at the end of 2025.”

 


 

These predictions represent our experts’ personal views based on their general market knowledge and industry experience. They are not based on any confidential information, nor should they be taken as financial advice or formal market guidance. As with all predictions, they’re more art than science – and we’ll have just as much fun looking back at how wrong (or right!) we were come December 2025.