Colin Robertson, HAL Experts founder, takes time to look at personal lines pricing

Having spent over fifteen years in personal lines pricing, one question has always fascinated me: what separates the good from the great?

My answer has always come back to what I think of as the art and the science. The science is the foundation.
Data, models, technical rigour. Most pricing functions do this reasonably well. But the art is something different: a feel for the market, an ability to form a hypothesis where the data is thin, and the creativity to spot an opportunity that a model alone would never surface. It’s the difference between knowing what the numbers say and knowing what they mean.

Over the years I’ve seen pricing philosophies that span the full spectrum, from daily trading decisions driven by live market signals to periodic optimisation cycles built entirely from the technical ground up. Neither is inherently right or wrong. What matters, in my experience, is whether the team running the approach genuinely understands what it’s pricing and owns its blind spots. Confidence without that self-awareness is where pricing strategies tend to come unstuck.

What concerns me now is a quiet shift I think is already underway. As machine learning, GBMs and ever-more-sophisticated modelling tools become central to pricing, there’s a real risk that the pricing artists, those with the instinct, the experience, and the creative judgement to navigate uncertainty, become increasingly rare, replaced by teams who are guided by the model but blinded by it too. The science is getting better. But I’m not sure it’s getting better at producing a better result.

I take some comfort from the watch industry. The assumption was that quartz and digital would make the master watchmaker obsolete. It didn’t. The artisans found their place, and their value was arguably better understood for the contrast.

I hope pricing follows a similar path. But it probably won’t happen by accident.